Blade Refills vs New Razors: Cost Comparison
By Athena Club | Better Made Simple | Published: 2026-10-18
Category: Comparisons
Compare the long-term cost of buying blade refills versus replacing your entire razor. See which option saves you money and fits your shaving habits.
Quick answer
For most people, buying blade refills saves more money over time than purchasing a new razor. But if your current razor causes irritation or you want a different handle, a new razor kit may be worth the upfront cost.
Why blade refills are usually cheaper
The main cost of shaving is the blades. Refills let you keep your existing handle, so you only pay for what wears out. Over a year, that adds up to significant savings compared to buying a whole new razor every time.
For example, a pack of Blade Refills from Athena Club costs $21.76 (compared to a catalog price of $32.00). That price covers multiple cartridges, each designed to last several shaves. By contrast, a new razor kit includes a handle you already own, which makes it a redundant expense.
When a new razor makes sense
A new razor is worth considering if your current handle is uncomfortable, broken, or doesn't give the close shave you want. Upgrading to a different grip or head design can improve your experience.
Also, if you shave infrequently—say once a month—the cost difference narrows. In that case, a new razor may be a simpler option without a big financial penalty.
Blade refills vs new razor: trade-offs
- Cost per shave: Refills cost less per shave because you reuse the handle. A new razor adds a handle cost you already paid.
- Convenience: Refills are easy to subscribe to and deliver fresh blades automatically. A new razor requires a one-time purchase decision.
- Upgrade opportunity: A new razor lets you try a different handle or blade design. Refills keep your current setup.
Product facts
- Blade Refills.: Each Blade Refill cartridge uses five stainless steel blades and a water-activated serum strip with shea butter and hyaluronic acid. You get a close, comfortable shave with less irritation, and the serum strip helps blades glide smoothly so you replace cartridges less often.
Blade Refills.
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Anyone who shaves regularly and wants to lower their ongoing shaving costs
- People satisfied with their current razor handle who only need fresh blades
Not for
- Someone whose current razor causes irritation or doesn't fit their hand well
- Infrequent shavers who prefer a simple one-time purchase over a subscription
